Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Recognizing Lt. Colonel Mike Hudson

I wanted to separate my regular meeting summary from the presentation that we made last night.

This is the statement I made to recognize Lt. Colonel Mike Hudson as one of Clayton's Unsung Heroes:
Lieutenant Colonel Mike Hudson, United States Marine Corps, retired

Tonight, I have the privilege of recognizing Lieutenant Colonel Mike Hudson, United States Marine Corps, retired, as one of Clayton's Unsung Heroes.

Mike is local – he grew up in Concord and graduated from De La Salle. Beginning his military career as an enlisted Marine, he served our country for 25 years as a Marine Corps infantry and reconnaissance officer, including multiple combat deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan. He led Force Reconnaissance Marines and commanded an infantry company during combat operations in Iraq, retiring with the rank of lieutenant colonel.

But Mike's commitment to service did not end with his military career. In 2009, Mike was the keynote speaker at Clayton’s Memorial Day ceremony. And again for the next few years – missing a couple due to deployments. And since 2019, Mike has taken the lead in planning and organizing Clayton's annual Memorial Day ceremony. It is an important tradition in our community, and one that Mike approaches with the seriousness and respect it deserves.

Mike understands the profound significance of Memorial Day. It is not a day for politicians to give speeches or draw attention to themselves, but a solemn occasion to remember those who made the ultimate sacrifice for our country. Under his leadership, Clayton's ceremonies have always reflected that understanding. Elected officials take a step back, and the focus remains where it belongs - on our fallen service members, their families, and the freedoms their sacrifices have preserved.

That is something I have always respected and appreciated about Mike's leadership. He ensures that we never lose sight of what Memorial Day is truly about.

Mike's dedication to service extends well beyond Memorial Day. He has organized events to honor fallen Marines and raise funds for Gold Star families, helped Afghan allies and former colleagues escape and resettle following the fall of Kabul, and raised funds to support Ukraine after the loss of a fellow officer and friend. For Mike, honoring those who have served isn't something reserved for a particular day of the year. It is a responsibility he continues to carry through his actions.

Mike has dedicated much of his life to serving others, first as an Officer of Marines and now as a member of our community. Much of that work happens quietly, without recognition or fanfare, which is precisely why this Unsung Hero recognition is so appropriate.

On behalf of the City Council and the residents of Clayton, thank you, Mike, for your service to our country, your continued service to our community, and for ensuring that Clayton never forgets those who gave their lives for our freedom.

It is my honor to recognize Lieutenant Colonel Mike Hudson as a Clayton Unsung Hero.

My 11.17.26 Meeting Summary

Last night, the Council held a hearing on the appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of the proposed Peacock Creek Townhomes development.

The Council discussed several concerns raised in the appeal, particularly wildfire evacuation, geotechnical conditions, environmental review, and the City's existing easements on the property. We also received clarification from staff and legal counsel on several important issues.

Wildfire Evacuation and Secondary Access

One of the key issues discussed was whether the project's proposed secondary emergency access point onto Clayton Road could also be used by residents to evacuate during a wildfire.

Staff explained that the current design does not permit residents to use this access point because it would create an uncontrolled intersection onto a major arterial road within approximately 800 feet of an existing signal-controlled intersection.

I questioned this restriction because a similar situation exists at Clayton's community park, where an uncontrolled access point connects to the same arterial road approximately 1,000 feet from a controlled intersection.  When I asked who establishes and controls these restrictions, staff suggested that the community park access may have received a variance. I pointed out that if a variance is available, the City may have the authority to grant it.

I asked staff to return with clarification on the applicable traffic and access regulations, who has authority to approve exceptions, and whether the City could permit the secondary access point to function as an additional evacuation route for residents.  This is particularly important because the property is designated as a Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone. While the current design provides secondary access for emergency responders, it does not provide residents with a second evacuation route.

The question is whether that restriction is legally required or whether the City has discretion to allow an additional exit that could improve evacuation options during an emergency. No determination was made on that question during the hearing.

Geotechnical Conditions and Drainage

The Council sought clarification regarding the existing geotechnical studies, the property's historic landslide conditions, and the drainage infrastructure supporting slope stability.

During the discussion, it was acknowledged that the functionality of the existing drainage system had not been confirmed because of conditions at the time of the examination.  We also clarified that the Geologic Hazard Abatement District's (GHAD) inclinometer monitoring in other areas does not include this particular property.

These are important issues that warrant further examination as part of the updated environmental review.

Environmental Review and the CEQA Standard

The Council received clarification from a CEQA attorney regarding the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and its fair-argument standard.

Under CEQA, the threshold for requiring a more comprehensive Environmental Impact Report (EIR) is relatively low. An EIR is required when substantial evidence in the record supports a fair argument that a project may have a significant environmental impact, even if other substantial evidence supports the opposite conclusion.

Importantly, this standard does not require proof that a significant environmental impact will actually occur, nor does it require proof that the impact cannot ultimately be mitigated. Rather, the question is whether substantial evidence supports a reasonable possibility of significant environmental effects despite the mitigation currently proposed.

This distinction is important because environmental experts may reach different conclusions based on the same evidence. Under the fair-argument standard, the existence of contrary expert opinions does not necessarily eliminate the requirement for an EIR.  

The Council discussed how this standard applies to the project's wildfire evacuation and geotechnical issues. Staff will conduct additional analysis and prepare a revised Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND). If that analysis identifies substantial evidence supporting a fair argument that significant impacts may remain despite proposed mitigation, an EIR may be required.

City Easements and Property Rights

I also emphasized an important distinction concerning the City's existing easements on the property.

The City holds certain easement rights, including a public service easement and a pathway easement. I made clear that releasing or modifying those rights is a policy decision for the City, not an automatic requirement resulting from the property's rezoning or the proposed development.

The City Attorney confirmed that distinction.

In other words, the City is not obligated to surrender its property rights simply because a developer proposes a different use for the land. Any decision to release or modify those rights should be considered independently and based on the public interest and is at the discretion of the Council.

Council's Decision and Next Steps

Following the discussion, the Council agreed with staff's recommendation and directed that:

  1. Staff prepare and recirculate an updated Mitigated Negative Declaration addressing the identified environmental issues.

  2. The public hearing on the appeal be continued to a future date, which will be separately noticed.

  3. The updated environmental review return directly to the City Council for further consideration and action.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Upcoming Meeting 11.17.26

At our next meeting, we will be discussing a couple of significant items:

Please note that we will begin earlier than usual, with closed session starting at 6:30 p.m. The regular public meeting will begin at 7:00 p.m., or shortly after closed session concludes.

- We will recognize retired Marine Corps Lieutenant Colonel Mike Hudson as Clayton's Unsung Hero. Mike served 25 years in the Marines and has led the organization of Clayton's annual Memorial Day ceremony since 2019, ensuring we honor those who made the ultimate sacrifice.

- We will consider the appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of the proposed 30-unit Peacock Creek Townhomes development.

The appeal raises several issues, including wildfire risk, emergency access and evacuation, geotechnical conditions, and cumulative impacts from nearby development. The Council has two primary options:
  1. Grant the appeal - Reverse the Planning Commission's existing approvals based on a determination that the findings were not adequately supported by the evidence.
  2. Deny the appeal - Uphold the Planning Commission's original approvals and associated findings.
Separately, City staff recommends continuing the appeal to allow revisions and recirculation of the environmental analysis before Council makes a final decision. A central question is whether the Planning Commission's original findings were sufficiently supported, particularly given the additional analysis staff now recommends.

If you have any thoughts or questions on the above, please let me know.

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

On Concerts History, Succession, and Oversight

Normally I try not to rehash what may or may not have been done optimally by staff.  It has always been more important to me to focus forward, how to mkae progress based on the best available information.  But given the amount of politicization going on, I wanted to clarify a few items.  First, let's talk about a bit of history:

At our April 19, 2022 meeting, I raised the issue and it was established that the way the City was accounting for concert funds was not appropriate.  Staff at the time indicated that rather than record inflows and outflows through revenue and expense accounts, all activity was recorded against a liability.  This is a bit technical, but the issue with recording concert activity through a liability account is not that the money was necessarily mishandled. It's that this approach keeps the financial activity out of the City's normal operating statements, budgets, and financial reporting.

For example, if the City collects $50,000 in donations and spends $45,000 on concerts, the Council and public should see both figures, not just the $5,000 remaining.  While individual transactions are recorded, the revenue and expenses do not appear in the City's operating results or budget to actual reports. In fact, because of this there was never any budget established.  As a result, the Council does not have the same opportunity to review, or oversee these activities as it does other City programs.

Here is our former City Manager discussing it:

And to further explain, our former Finance Director:

At this same meeting, it was also established that the concerts had always been City events.  Any discussion now that says or implies it was not a City event is incorrect.  Here is former Councilmember Cloven stating this fact:

And when referencing Concerts as a City event, the one who first brought up the idea of oversight was Councilmember Tillman:

And further discussion of how such oversight could occur:

The fact that the concerts were City events, not volunteer owned, was established in April 2022, when former Councilmembers Cloven and Wolfe were on the Council, along with Councilmembers Tilman, Diaz, and myself.  This is when the discussion of oversight was started, as it was clear at the time that activity wasn't being recorded as it should have been.

During this same meeting, given the Concerts were City events, we also discussed the idea of a succession plan for continuity and sustainability of the events.  Here is our former City Manager discussing how succession could work:


And in that meeting, Howard Geller called in and also talked about succession:

This is quite a bit different than Geller stated at our 10.20.26 meeting.  At that meeting, Geller made the claim that after he booked the bands and signed the contracts (which would also be inappropriate) for the 2023 season, he decided to retire because the City was taking over.  However, in the January 2023 issue of the Pioneer (https://issuu.com/claytonpioneerinc./docs/jan_20_the_pioneer_2023), Geller stated he was already planning to retire at the end of the 2023 summer concert season and that it had nothiing to do with the oversight committee - directly contradicting his 10.20.26 statement:

At the 10.20.26 meeting, Geller went on to claim that the City didn't consider any of the knowledge or experience he had after being involved for the length of his tenure.  Of course, this is also not true.

During the summer of 2023, Councilmember Trupiano spent extensive amounts of time shadowing Geller and documenting the practices and processes that were previously undocumented and informal.  In fact, here is an email from February 2023 where Geller expresses favorable comments regarding the transition:

Given the actual history, it may seem odd that the tune of so many involved in the Concerts changed.  Originally after identifying financial irregularities, all were in agreement that oversight was necessary, that proper recording was necessary, that succession planning was necessary, and that the current folks involved were planning to retire.  An orderly transition is always preferable.  So what changed?

Let's look at the timeline:
  • Apr 2022 - Financial accountability, Council oversight, and succession planning identified as priorities.  Established that historical accounting of concerts done inappropriately.
  • Dec 2022 - Council unanimously establishes dedicated concert oversight.
  • Jan 2023 - Geller states his intention to retire after the 2023 season and confirms it was unrelated to new oversight committee
  • Feb 2023 - Geller reiterates his intention to retire and speaks favorably about Council involvement
  • Mar 2023 - City terminates Master Use Agreement (MUA) with CBCA that provided for waiving essentially all fees
  • Mar 2023 - In response to the termination of the MUA, AJ Chippero who had previously agreed to do promotion of the Concerts as has been done in the past, rescinds his contract, leaving the City without promotion
  • Spring 2023 - Councilmember Trupiano assumes all sponsorship activity as Julie Pierce, who was formerly involved in securing sponsorships, did not return any phone calls or attempts to make contact.  Under Trupiano's leaadership, sponsorship increases significantly.  CBCA had previously contributed at least $5K each year to the Concert series, however after the cancellation of the MUA, concert donation for that year was $500, and after that zero for every year thereafter.  It is completely the perogative of any organization whether or not to make a donation.
It seems pretty clear what caused folks to change their tune.

At the same time, the Committee was focused on ensuring that the concert and other special event activty were recorded propertly, and completely.  Historically, certain City costs were not allocated to the concerts or other activities that were being supported.  This means that any purported "surplus" from 16 years of activity, benefited from the fact that the City was subsidizing the activity and not recording those charges against the concerts.  Things like police, administrative staff, maintenance, these were not consistently or at times ever charged to these programs.  Here is our City Manager addressing the matter of apples to apples comparison:


This is why my previous post called the current posturing theater, and that's being generous.  Given the fact pattern, it's manufactured outrage. Comparing current period activity where things are being accurately tracked, to historical results that were not, is misleading at best.  Any activity can appear great if costs aren't included.

Friday, October 23, 2026

Concerts in the Grove: Reality vs. Political Theater

Recently there has been conversation around the Concerts in the Grove series, how they are operated and managed, and the overall finances of the concerts.  This appears to be an attempt to politicize the concerts which is unfortunate.

First to clarify a few items:

- The concerts are not intended to be a profit making endeavor.  They are held as a general community benefit and part of the activities in the City that bring people together.  Similar to the 4th of July Parade, or National Night Out - these things cost money but the City chooses to do them because they benefit the community.  The City does accept donations and sponsorhips which are great, but making money is not the goal of the concerts.

- There are two primary revenue sources for the concerts - sponsorships and donations.  Sponsorships can be for the concerts alone, or for multiple City events. This revenue goes 100% to the choices the sponsors make.  Donations made at the concerts themselves, or online with the QR code on the various jugs are split 50/50 with our two local school Parent Faculty Clubs - Mt. Diablo Elementary and Diablo View Middle PFCs.  Because it was difficult to reliably secure volunteers to collect funds, the City partnered with the local PFCs to provide volunteers.  This partnership provides reliable collection volunteers, and allows the City to provide direct support to our local children.  At our last Council meeting representatives from the PFCs accepted their checks and it was great to hear from them.  At DVMS, we heard how the leadership class took on responsibility of organizing the volunteers, which is also a great avenue for students to participate.

The City could attempt to monetize the concerts further - We could cease sharing with the PFC.  We could more aggressively seek donations from concert goers.  We could discontinue the utilization of a stage.  We could reduce or eliminate security.  We could reduce or cease advertising.  But all of these take away from the event or the community in some way.

- The idea that the concerts were previously run by volunteers is misleading.  Volunteers have contributed time and effort in varying degrees, but the concerts have always been a City event.  The City provided the venue.  The City provided the insurance.  The City collected and accounted for the funds collected and disbursed.  The City provided security.  And ultimately, the City signed contracts with the performers.

- One of the reasons the City took a greater hand in managing the concerts, and all other City events, was to make City events more sustainable.  Depending on volunteers for critical functions means that  if a key role was unable to be performed for any reason, the event would at risk.  It is not only financial sustainability, but operational sustainability.  For example, in 2023, right about when promotion for the concerts was about to kick off, former Planning Commissioner and promoter A.J. Chippero, quit and resicnded his offer of services because he was unhappy with Council decisions.  Here is the email he sent:
This is the same individual who was paid to manage the Clayton Concerts FB page (now unaffiliated with the City apparently) and has been criticizing the use of a promoter, among other things.  Ironic.  In addition, another person that had previously been responsible for securing sponsorships didn't return phone calls and apparently moved out of the area around the same time - as a result Councilmember Trupiano took on the role of securing sponsorships for all of the City events.

Prior to 2023, former Mayor Howard Geller was the person most princpally involved in the concerts.  Mr. Geller negotiated the rates and instructed the City what to pay the bands.  If the amount negotiated and the amount paid was different, there would be no way the City would know.  Here is Mr. Geller at a Council meeting in March 2023:


If a vendor working for the City behaved this way, it would not be prudent to rely on this vendor to provide critical services that a City event relied on.  This again highlights why it is not sustainable to rely on volunteers for critical functions - the City must be able to make decisions in the best interests of the community as a whole without risk that our events may be in jeopardy.

And on the issue of sponsorships, here is a lookback on the level of sponsorships that the City has secured:

2018: $24,200
2019: $21,375
2020: $0
2021: $2,608
2022: $24,570
2023: $31,500
2024: $54,500
2025: $40,700
2026: $47,600

A few items to note: 2020 was during the pandemic and there were no events held that year.  2021 was also abreviated.  After the previous volunteer who secured sponsorships in the past did not return phone calls nor provide any support, Councilmember Trupiano took over securing all sponsorships begining in 2023, her first full year on the Council.  Part of securing sponsorships is communicating to sponsors the benefit they will receive.  Prominent placement on our banners, on the stage, and in our advertising can encourage more sponsorships.  I think the results speak for themselves.

The Concerts are a wonderful addition to our community.  The reality is that much like a lot of the quality of life items that exist, they cost money.  One of the benefits of the City taking a greater role in managing the concerts, is that they can be accounted for and operated properly.  

Case in point: 
  • Historically, costs for things like police, security, advertising, city staff time, or other overhead items were not charged to the concerts.  But that doesn't give a true picture of what they cost and the City has updated how it accounts for all of the City sponsored activity.  That means historically, the true financial activity of the concerts were not accounted for.
  • Previously, the volunteers took it upon themselves to block off the Grove Park and not allow people to set up chairs during the day.  This was well intentioned, but illegal and unenforceable.  If a person wanted to use the public park by putting a towel or a chair there, volunteer or no, there was no legal basis that would support taking any action. 
  • Historically, the performers were required to have insurance, but there was no record of anyone verifying that the insurance existed.  
  • There was no documented procedures for how the concerts were run, which meant that individuals were holding themselves out as representatives, or agents of the City, with no City oversight.  If anything were to happen, the City could still be liable.
All of these things increase risk to the City.  Establishing City oversight, documented processes, and professional services does take time and money.  So does holding the 4th of July parade.  So does maintaining City parks.  So does even turning on things like the splash pad, or the fountain, or any number of things the City does to enhance the quality of life in our town.  It's unfortunate that somehow these community benefits are being wielded to score political points.  I would much rather celebrate all the wonderful things that we enjoy in our community than attack the things that make our town a great place to live.

Wednesday, October 21, 2026

10.20.26 Meeting Summary and Claycord's Misleading Reporting on Clayton's Investments

Much of our discussion at our Tuesday meeting was regarding the investment reports, and providing context to a misleading article that appeared on Claycord.  Claycord's October 20 article about the City of Clayton's investments is a textbook example of how technically accurate facts can be assembled into a deeply misleading story. The article emphasizes investment policy violations, a $142,000 realized loss, and missing quarterly reports. What it fails to explain is why those events occurred, and what the City's investment decisions actually accomplished.

This information was not hidden from the public. The Council's investment strategy was discussed in open meetings, with supporting materials published in advance. A review of that public record would have produced a substantially different story. Instead, Claycord chose an alarming headline and a narrative of apparent financial mismanagement, without providing readers the information necessary to evaluate either.

Claycord Missed the Most Important Story: The Council Deliberately Improved Investment Returns

In May 2023, the City Council recognized that its investment portfolio was not taking advantage of the prevailing interest rate environment.  At the time, the portfolio was yielding approximately 1.88%, with a substantial concentration in certificates of deposit (CDs), many purchased when interest rates were considerably lower. Meanwhile, market interest rates had increased significantly, creating opportunities to earn substantially more on safe, highly liquid investments.

The Council understood this disparity and deliberately revised its investment policy on May 2, 2023. The new policy reduced allowable CD concentration to 30% and supported greater investment in U.S. Treasury securities. Our objective was to take advantage of higher available yields while maintaining safety and liquidity.  By September 30, 2026, the portfolio's estimated weighted-average stated interest rate had increased to approximately 3.8%, based on the investment schedule reviewed at the October 20 Council meeting.

That is approximately double the original rate.

For a city managing approximately $12 million in investments, that improvement is financially significant. Yet Claycord's article provides no meaningful discussion of the original portfolio's low yield, the Council's rationale for changing the investment policy, or the subsequent improvement.  In fact, adopting the stricter policy itself created the principal compliance exception highlighted in the article.

The Policy Exceptions Were Not a Newly Discovered Problem

Claycord reports that the City exceeded its 30% CD concentration limit for five consecutive quarters. That is accurate, but the article omits the circumstances that created the condition.  When we adopted the stricter policy in May 2023, we knew the existing portfolio exceeded the new CD limit.  The concentration exceptions were therefore an anticipated consequence of changing the policy, not evidence that the Council was unaware of its investments.

The City subsequently brought the portfolio into compliance with its measurable investment limits beginning March 31, 2025. The report also identifies other exceptions, including two CDs purchased after the policy change with terms exceeding the permitted limit. Those are separate issues that warrant follow-up.  A responsible article would have distinguished the expected transition from those additional exceptions. Claycord did not.

The $142,000 Loss Was Not an Unexplained Investment Failure

Claycord prominently features a $142,222 realized investment loss in early 2025 but provides virtually no explanation of the underlying investment decision. On February 4, 2025, the Council publicly considered and approved transitioning to professional investment management through UBS.

The agenda packet explained that the City's existing portfolio was not capturing available investment opportunities. Some CDs were earning less than 1%, while substantially higher yields were available on U.S. Treasury securities. Selling those investments before maturity involved a cost. The financial rationale was that reinvesting the proceeds at higher rates was expected to generate enough additional income over time to justify that cost.

The realized loss was associated with that deliberate portfolio repositioning. It was not an unexpected speculative trading loss. Whether the decision ultimately produced a positive financial return should be evaluated by comparing the cost of exiting the CDs with the additional income generated by replacement investments.

Claycord did none of that analysis. It presented the loss as an alarming standalone figure, despite the public record explaining the City's investment strategy. That is not meaningful financial analysis. It is selective reporting.

Claycord Left Out the Context and Publicly Available Investment Statements

The article also highlights nearly three years of missing quarterly investment reports. That reporting requirement was not met, and it should have been. There is no reason to minimize that deficiency. But Claycord again leaves out important context.

The Council was aware of the backlog. Preparing these reports was a labor-intensive process requiring staff to manually compile detailed investment information. With limited staff and competing priorities, the Council directed that underlying investment statements be made available on the City's website.

Staff continued reviewing investment information, and the underlying statements remained publicly available. The absence of the formal reports did not mean the investments were unmonitored.

The City has also substantially improved its reporting process. Staff now use AI-assisted tools to complete work that previously took days or weeks in hours or less, while retaining responsibility for reviewing and validating the results. Posting statements did not fulfill the formal reporting requirement. But that is a very different situation from the impression of secrecy or financial neglect created by the article.

The Actual Financial Results Were Substantial

The same October 20 report cited by Claycord shows that, over ten complete quarters, the City generated:

  • $1.13 million in gross investment income.
  • $947,000 in net investment earnings after management fees and realized losses.
  • Sufficient projected resources to cover six months of anticipated expenditures throughout the period.
Claycord briefly mentions these results but gives them almost no meaningful analysis.

It is difficult to understand the City's financial management without examining its investment performance, the purpose of the policy changes, or the economic rationale for repositioning the portfolio. A $142,000 realized loss makes for an alarming headline. Explaining the investment decisions behind it takes a little more effort, or journalism.

The Council deliberately revised its investment policy in May 2023 to take advantage of higher market interest rates. The portfolio's estimated stated interest rate subsequently increased from approximately 1.88% to 3.8%. We publicly discussed our investment strategy, approved professional management in February 2025, and brought the portfolio into compliance. We also improved the reporting process to address the administrative burden on our small staff.

The missing context was readily available through public Council meetings and published agenda materials.  Claycord did not need special access or an extensive investigation to find it. It simply needed to examine the decisions behind the numbers rather than select the numbers that made for the most alarming headline.

Saturday, October 17, 2026

Upcoming Meeting 10.26.26 and Townhall Q&A 10.24.26

At our next meeting, we will be having a few items in our Recognitions and Presentations section, including the presentation of funds to the Parent Faculty Clubs for MDE and DVMS, as well as our Do the Right Thing recognition as well as a presentation by County Supervisor Carlson.

I'd also like to announce that I will be hosting a Townhall Q&A at 3pm on Saturday, October 24 at 3pm in Hoyer Hall adjacent to the library.